Rep. Thomas Massie (R-Ky.) said Thursday that President Donald Trump cannot dismiss Vice President JD Vance from office despite their differing public statements about the political consequences of the Iran war, noting that the vice president holds a constitutional office rather than a position serving at the president’s discretion.
Massie made the remarks during a November 19 interview with Kaitlan Collins on CNN’s The Source, after Collins asked about Trump’s frustration with Vance’s assessment that the war had contributed to Republican losses in the midterm elections.
“Well, JD Vance is the one guy that President Trump can’t fire. I think it’s an interesting dynamic,” Massie said.
“He could get rid of his chief of staff, his Cabinet secretaries, but JD Vance is there to the end until he legitimately does resign, if he did want to leave. I’m not saying he did.”
Massie continued: “But it’s an interesting dynamic. The Vice President is there. He’s not employment at-will. He’s in the Constitution.”
The comments followed public differences between Trump and Vance over how Republicans should assess the Iran war after losing control of the House and Senate in the November 3 elections. Vance attributed the defeats to the conflict and its consequences for voters, while Trump maintained that the decision to launch military operations was justified.
In a November 4 statement on X, Vance said Republicans needed to acknowledge the effect of the war on their electoral prospects. He pointed to voters who had supported the Trump-Vance ticket in 2024 but backed Democrats in the midterms, citing the conflict, living costs and other foreign policy concerns.
Vance said the party needed to address the war’s political cost rather than attribute the losses solely to campaign strategy or voter turnout. His statement raised questions about the administration’s position on continuing the conflict, which began with U.S. and Israeli strikes against Iran in February.
Trump subsequently said he agreed that the war had contributed to the election results but wanted Vance to make clear that the decision to attack Iran was justified. The president has repeatedly defended the military campaign as necessary to prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon.
The president’s comments also followed changes to Vance’s responsibilities. After the vice president participated in negotiations intended to reach an agreement with Iran, Trump redirected his attention toward domestic priorities. Vance’s involvement in those diplomatic efforts had placed him among the administration officials working on a possible negotiated end to the fighting.
On November 20, a day after Massie’s CNN interview, Trump publicly addressed the disagreement during a White House press conference, saying he had not been unhappy with Vance’s assessment. Trump said he would have wanted the vice president to add that the military operation remained necessary despite its political consequences, according to Reuters’ account of the exchange.
Vance, appearing alongside Trump, defended the administration’s objective of preventing Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons but declined to say whether he personally would have ordered the initial strikes. He said the decision belonged to the president and that his responsibility was to support Trump’s decisions.
Trump’s public response did not indicate that he intended to remove Vance from office. Massie likewise did not suggest during his CNN appearance that Vance was considering resignation or that an effort to remove him was underway.
Under the U.S. Constitution, the vice presidency is an elected constitutional office. Unlike Cabinet secretaries and senior White House staff, a vice president cannot be dismissed unilaterally by the president. A vice president can resign, leave office at the end of a term or be removed through the constitutional impeachment process.
The 25th Amendment establishes procedures for filling a vacancy in the vice presidency, requiring the president’s nominee to be confirmed by a majority vote in both houses of Congress. It does not give the president authority to dismiss a sitting vice president.
Massie’s remarks came immediately after he outlined plans to seek another congressional vote on ending the Iran war. He said he wanted Republicans who had previously supported continuing the conflict to reconsider their positions following the midterm results.
Massie introduced H.Con.Res. 126 on November 10, directing the withdrawal of U.S. forces from hostilities against Iran unless Congress specifically authorizes the operations or certain defensive conditions apply. The proposal remains separate from a war powers resolution that the Senate rejected by a vote of 48–51 on November 19.
The Kentucky Republican is serving his final weeks in Congress after losing his primary earlier this year. His comments about Vance addressed the constitutional limits on Trump’s authority over the vice president, while his proposed war powers vote would require lawmakers to revisit their positions on the conflict before the current Congress ends.